← All articles Prop Firms / Portfolio Check

Will Your Portfolio Pass a Prop Firm Challenge? How to Check Before You Pay

You've built a portfolio and you want to use it to win capital from a prop firm. Congratulations. One question is left: will it actually meet the firm's rules? A profitable portfolio can still fail a challenge on a single bad day. This is the final video in my prop firm series, and it shows how to check your portfolio against the rules before you pay for a challenge, and what to change when it falls short.

Risk note. Trading involves substantial risk of loss. The portfolio, returns and capital figures below come from a backtest used for teaching, not a recommendation to trade it, and there's no guarantee you'll pass a challenge or make money. A backtest return of 114.7% says nothing certain about live results.

The Three Rules Prop Firms Actually Judge You On

Let me remind you first: this is a serious job. Good traders manage up to tens of millions under prop firms and make very serious money. But you're competing with a lot of other traders, some of them maybe smarter than you, so you need the best techniques and tools you can get.

The portfolio here is the one from earlier in the series: three opening-gap breakout strategies on E-mini Nasdaq, built in BreakoutOS, with the weakest days of the week removed and everything combined into one portfolio. On paper it looks good. The question is whether it would get you funded.

Prop firm rules aren't always 100% clear. Sometimes that's a lack of transparency. Often it's because the firm runs its own internal risk model with many variables, and it doesn't publish every rule in full. That's not a bad thing, it's just how it is. So you can't predict a firm's decision precisely. You can estimate it, and that's already enough.

Because when it comes to risk and objectives, prop firms mostly care about three things:

  • Maximum drawdown. Very often 10% of the account, measured from your equity peak. Cross it and you're out.
  • Maximum daily loss. In this example, 5%. A portfolio can pass the overall drawdown test and still fail on its worst day.
  • Return target. In this example, 10%. The profit you need to make to get funded.

These numbers are illustrative. Every firm sets its own, so plug in your firm's current rules.

How Much Capital Your Portfolio Needs: $301,600 or $30,160

In the BreakoutOS Portfolio Builder there's a node called Prop-firm Fit. You connect it to your portfolio, set the three rules above, and it immediately tells you the capital you'd need to meet all of them.

Why capital? Because every one of these rules is a percentage of your account. To stay inside a drawdown limit you need to be properly capitalized. I covered the math in how much capital you need for a prop firm challenge, and it's the most important thing to understand about prop firms.

For this portfolio on regular E-mini Nasdaq contracts, the minimum capital comes out at $301,600. Don't get scared by that. E-mini Nasdaq is one of the wildest, most volatile markets in the world right now, and it's for professionals with bigger accounts.

Most traders will use micro contracts, which are one tenth of the regular contract. Switch the micro toggle on and everything recalculates: the same portfolio needs about $30,160.

ContractMinimum capital (static backtest)
E-mini Nasdaq$301,600
Micro Nasdaq$30,160

This figure is based on the closed-trade backtest equity curve. It's an approximation, since an exact simulation of a firm's rules isn't possible, but it gives you a strong starting point.

Why a $25,000 Account Still Fails One Test

You can also enter your own account size and see how far you are from each rule. Here's a $25,000 account on micros:

RuleLimitResultVerdict
Maximum drawdown10%8.8%Passes
Worst day5%6.0%Fails
Backtest return10% target114.7%Well above target

The drawdown is fine and the return clears the target easily. But one bad day in the backtest lost 6% of the account, and with a 5% daily limit that day alone would end the challenge.

The rule to remember

Check your worst day separately from your maximum drawdown. A portfolio can pass one and fail the other, and either failure ends the challenge.

Static Backtest vs Monte Carlo: $30,160 vs $49,969

All the numbers so far come from the static backtest: one sample, the data as it is right now. In part two of the series I showed why Monte Carlo analysis is much more conservative, and much more realistic. It reshuffles the order of your trades many times and looks at the drawdowns that could happen.

Switch the Prop-firm Fit view to Monte Carlo and the capital needed jumps from $30,160 to almost $50,000 ($49,969).

So how do you deal with that? It's up to you. You can work with the Monte Carlo figure and stay on the conservative side, which is what I'd recommend. Or you can go halfway between the static and Monte Carlo numbers, about $40,000 in this case. That's an illustration, not a prescribed account size.

One more tip. In the previous video of the series I shared ways to launch strategies at the best possible time, so you avoid a lot of losing days early on. If you follow those, even the static minimum capital could do the job. Again, that's your call.

See BreakoutOS in Action

Watch the Portfolio Builder check a portfolio against prop firm rules.

Watch Demo Videos  →

Find the Strategy That Causes Your Worst Day

Back to the failed test. Where does that worst day come from, and what can you do about it? Don't start optimizing at random. Diagnose it first.

The Strategy contributions tab shows which strategy is behind the largest drawdown. Here it's the NQ Opening Gap After Market FADE strategy. In the selected drawdown of $2,200, it contributed $1,451, about three times more than the next strategy ($511), with the third adding just $238.

Once you know that, you have two options. Replace the strategy completely, or work on it a little further and see if you can cut its drawdowns without overfitting. Overfitting is the real risk here: if you remove every losing period, you'll end up with a perfect backtest that falls apart in live trading.

Testing a day-of-week change

I went back to the day-of-week breakdown for the FADE strategy. Wednesday had about $15,000 of drawdown and Friday about $9,000. Wednesday can still get very volatile, so I tested removing it. Treat this as an experiment to show the process, not as trading advice.

For the full day-of-week and gap research behind these strategies, see Gap Trading Strategy: What 225 Opening Gap Tests on NASDAQ Showed.

What Removing Wednesday Changed (and What It Didn't)

Everything recalculates as soon as you make the change. Here's the before and after:

MetricBeforeAfter removing Wednesday
Maximum drawdown8.8%5.1%
Worst day6.0%3.8%
Backtest return114.7%90.5%
Static minimum capital$30,160$19,230

The capital needed fell from $30,160 to $19,230, more than a third lower, and the portfolio now meets all three static rules. The worst day is inside the 5% limit. The backtest return dropped, which is the trade-off you'd expect when you remove trades.

But this is still the static backtest. Run Monte Carlo again (300 runs, 95% drawdown coverage) and the recommended minimum is $38,341. On the $25,000 account, the Monte Carlo drawdown is 15.3%, well over the 10% limit. So the change helped a lot, and you still have work to do if you want to be on the conservative, realistic side.

This is one of the easiest ways to start improving a portfolio for prop firm rules. With the right tools it's quite simple. It needs focus and serious work, but the reward can be huge, so it's worth putting the time in.

A Pre-Challenge Checklist

  1. Confirm the firm's current rules. Maximum drawdown, daily loss limit and profit target, plus any rules they don't spell out clearly.
  2. Check the combined portfolio. Judge the portfolio as a whole, not each strategy alone.
  3. Pick a realistic contract size. If the E-mini number is out of reach, micros cut it to a tenth.
  4. Compare static and Monte Carlo. Size for Monte Carlo if you can, or at least somewhere in between.
  5. Find the main source of losses. See which strategy drives the worst drawdown.
  6. Change carefully. Test one change at a time and watch for overfitting.
  7. Reassess after every change. Run the static and Monte Carlo checks again before you pay.

Next, I'm going deeper into robustness testing and the individual robustness tests, which is how you make sure changes like the one above aren't just curve fitting. Until then, see how BreakoutOS validates strategy robustness.

Go deeper on prop firms

The Prop Firm Playbook takes this further: nine plays and six videos on building a portfolio that can pass the challenge, sizing your capital and getting funded. See The Prop Firm Playbook.

The Prop Firm Playbook - nine plays and six videos on passing the challenge, sizing your capital and getting funded
The Prop Firm Playbook. See what's inside →

Frequently Asked Questions

Most prop firms cap your total drawdown at around 10% of the account, measured from your peak equity. Go past it and the challenge or funded account ends, however profitable you were before. Some firms use a trailing drawdown that moves up with your highest balance, others a fixed one from your starting balance. The exact rule varies, so read your firm's current terms before you size anything.
It's the most you're allowed to lose in a single day, often around 5% of the account. Traders fail it because a portfolio can look fine on total drawdown and still have one very bad day hidden in its history. In this article's example, a $25,000 micro account stayed inside a 10% drawdown limit at 8.8% but its worst day was 6.0%, over a 5% daily limit. Check your worst day separately, not just your maximum drawdown.
It depends on the drawdown of what you trade, not on a fixed number. Capital needed is roughly your maximum dollar drawdown divided by the firm's allowed drawdown. For the three-strategy portfolio in this article, the backtest put the minimum at $301,600 on E-mini Nasdaq and $30,160 on micros. A Monte Carlo stress test raised the micro figure to $49,969. These are backtest estimates, not a guarantee of passing.
On most challenge-sized accounts, micros. Micro Nasdaq is one tenth the size of E-mini Nasdaq, so drawdowns, daily losses and the capital you need all drop to a tenth. E-mini Nasdaq is one of the most volatile markets in the world and suits much larger accounts. Contract limits and fees vary by firm, so check what yours allows.
No. Firms publish headline rules like maximum drawdown, daily loss and profit target, but many also run internal risk models they don't fully disclose. What you can do is check your portfolio against the published rules before you pay for a challenge, using both the backtest and a more conservative Monte Carlo estimate. That won't guarantee funding, but it tells you whether you're close or far off.
Tomas Nesnidal

About the Author

Tomas Nesnidal, known to the systematic trading community as Mr. Breakouts, is a breakout trading specialist, hedge fund co-founder, and creator of BreakoutOS. He has managed institutional portfolios using breakout strategies for over 15 years, trading from 65+ countries. He is the author of The Breakout Trading Revolution and co-founder of Breakout Trading Academy.